Risk analysis of chainsaw worker's motion and body posture using the REBA method in tree felling operations in forestry in western Guilan province

Document Type : Scientific article

Authors

1 MSc of Forestry, Faculty of Natural Resources, University of Guilan, Sowmeh Sara, Guilan, I. R. Iran

2 Associate Professor, Department of Forest science and engineering, Faculty of Natural Resources, University of Guilan, Sowmeh Sara, Guilan, I. R. Iran

3 Lab of Forest Utilization, Faculty of Forestry and Natural Environment, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, POB 227, Thessaloniki, Greece

Abstract

Background and Objective: Chainsaw-based felling is the predominant method of timber harvesting in the forest plantations of western Guilan Province. In these clear-cutting operations, operators are required to adopt various awkward body postures. Despite technological advancements and significant improvements in occupational health and safety (OHS) within the forestry sector, wood harvesting in this region remains heavily dependent on manual chainsaw operators. The repetitive and demanding physical postures assumed during these operations can lead to discomfort, increased risk of accidents, and long-term health issues. This study aimed to evaluate the body postures and repetitive movements of chainsaw operators during semi-mechanized felling of poplar (Populus spp.) trees, with the ultimate goal of improving operator comfort, safety, and occupational health.
Material and Methods: The study was conducted in the poplar plantations of District Two (Series 2), Gisum. A total of 430 body postures were recorded and analyzed across various work components, including moving between trees, undercutting, and back-cutting. Postural assessment was performed using the Rapid Entire Body Assessment (REBA) method. Operations were carried out using STIHL chainsaws. Data collection involved analyzing four hours of video recordings of the operators to identify different working postures. Scoring was then applied to various body regions, categorized into Group A (trunk, neck, and legs) and Group B (upper arm, lower arm, and wrist). Finally, based on the cumulative scores, five action levels were determined: Action Level 0 (low risk/unnecessary), 1 (negligible/may be necessary), 2 (medium/necessary), 3 (high/necessary as soon as possible), and 4 (very high/necessary immediately).
Results: The results indicated that the chainsaw operator's trunk was most frequently in a straight position during tree assessment (45.6%) and moving between trees (53.3%). In contrast, trunk flexion exceeding 60° was the most prevalent posture during undercutting (51.4%) and back-cutting (38.5%). Regarding neck positioning, the highest frequency during the tree assessment and undercutting phases was observed for extension or flexion exceeding 20° (54.4% and 51.9%, respectively). However, during back-cutting and moving between trees, neck extension/flexion of 0 to 20° was most common (46.7% and 53.3%, respectively). Analysis of leg postures showed that across all work phases, assessment, undercutting, back-cutting, and moving, the highest frequency corresponded to Code 1 (balanced weight distribution while walking or sitting). For upper arm positioning, Code 1 (20° forward or backward deviation) was the most frequent posture across the assessment, undercutting, back-cutting, and moving phases, with frequencies of 32.9%, 45.3%, 34.4%, and 46.7%, respectively. The forearm position most frequently recorded across all four work components was Code 1 (60–100° forward flexion). Similarly, wrist positioning across all stages predominantly fell under Code 2 (flexion or extension exceeding 15°). Overall, 0.7% of body postures were classified as Action Level 0, 13.71% as Action Level 1, 43.49% as Action Level 2, 34.89% as Action Level 3, and 7.20% reached Action Level 4.
Conclusion: The REBA analysis of felling components revealed that "tree assessment" and "moving between trees" fall under Action Level 2, indicating a need for further investigation and necessary ergonomic interventions to improve working conditions. Furthermore, the "undercutting" and "back-cutting" phases were classified as Action Level 4, necessitating immediate modifications to body postures during these tasks. The REBA index proved to be an effective tool for assessing musculoskeletal risks in forestry, particularly for felling operations. Integrating this method with other ergonomic assessment tools to evaluate various forestry operations could facilitate the acquisition of quality certifications for forestry companies.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Arman, Z.; Nikooy, M.; Heidari, M.; Majnonian, B., Ergonomic evaluation of the      musculoskeletal disorders risk by QEC method in forest harvesting. Iranian Journal of Forest 2019, 10(4), 517-530. (In Persian).
Arman, Z.; Rahimi, F.; Nikooy, M.; Heidari, M.; and Majnounian, B., Postural risk assessment of felling operation in a poplar plantation, Iran. Iranian Journal of Forest and Poplar Research 2020, 28(3), 296-307. (In Persian).
Bhattacharya, A., Costs of occupational musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs) in the United States. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 2014, 44(3), 448-454.
Dimou, V.; Malesios, Ch.; Pispa, S., Assessing forestry-related musculoskeletal symptoms in specific body areas. Interanational Journal of Forest Engineering 2020, 31(3), 233-41.
Enez, K.; Topbas, M.; Acar, H. H., An evaluation of the occupational accidents among logging workers within the boundaries of Trabzon Forestry Directorate, Turkey. International journal of industrial ergonomics 2014, 44(5), 621-628.
Enez, K.; Nalbantoğlu, S. S., Comparison of ergonomic risk assessment outputs from OWAS and REBA in forestry timber harvesting. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 2019, 70, 51-57.
Faiz Syuaib, M.; Yovi, E. Y.; Meysiska Sari, D. A., Motions and postural risk analysis by REBA on tree felling operation. Sustainable Forest Development in view of Climate Change (SFDCC2016) 2016, 86.
Gallo, R.; Mazzetto, F., Ergonomic analysis for the assessment of the risk of work-related musculoskeletal disorder in forestry operations. Journal of Agricultural Engineering 2013, 44(s2).730-735.
Gómez-Galán, M.; Pérez-Alonso, J.; Callejón-Ferre, Á. J.; López-Martínez, J., Musculoskeletal disorders: OWAS review. Industrial health 2017, 55(4), 314-337.
Hignett, S.; McAtamney, L., Rapid entire body assessment (REBA). Applied ergonomics 2000, 31(2), 201-205.
ILO (International Labour Organization). Global trends on occupational accidents and diseases. World Day Saf. Health Work, 1, 1-7. 2005
Landekić, M.; Katuša, S.; Mijoč, D.; Šporčić, M., Assessment and comparison of machine operators’ working posture in forest thinning. South-east European forestry: SEEFOR 2019, 10(1), 29-37.
Lowe, B.D.; Dempsey, P.G.; Jones, E.M., Ergonomics assessment methods used by ergonomics professionals. Applied Ergonomics 2019, 81(10),13-20.
Lynch, S. M.; Smidt, M.; Merrill, P. D.; Sesek, R. F., Incidence of MSDs and neck and back pain among logging machine operators in the southern US. Journal of agricultural safety and health 2014, 20(3), 211-218.
Manavakun, N. A comparison of OWAS and REBA observational techniques for assessing postural loads in tree felling and processing. In FEC–FORMEC–2004 conference, October 8-12 Dubrovnik (Cavtat). 2004
Martins, A. B.; Lopes, Es.; Pagnussat, Mb.; Fiedler, Nc.; Oliveira, Fm., Upper limb posture and movement during tracked versus wheeled harvester operation on Pinus thinning. International Journal of Forest Engineering 2020, 31(3), 263-271.
McAtamney, L.; Corlett, E. N., RULA: a survey method for the investigation of work-related upper limb disorders. Applied ergonomics 1993, 24(2), 91-99.
Micheletti Cremasco, M.; Giustetto, A.; Caffaro, F.; Colantoni, A.; Cavallo, E.; Grigolato, S., Risk assessment for musculoskeletal disorders in forestry: A comparison between RULA and REBA in the manual feeding of a wood-chipper. International journal of environmental research and public health 2019, 16(5), 793.
Nikooy, M.; Nourozi, Z.; Naghdi, R., Survey of felling and bucking operation’s safety in Shafaroud watershed. Forest Research and Development 2016, 1(3), 209-219. (In Persian).
Paini, A. D. C.; Lopes, E. D. S.; Fiedler, N. C.; de Souza, A. P.; Rodrigues, C. K., Postural analysis and repetitive motions of skidder operators in wood extraction. Scientia Forestalis 2020, 48 (125), e3008.
Rahimi Bitam, F.; Nikooy, M.; Ghajar, E., Ranking the dangers of working with chainsaw during felling operation. Journal of Forest Research and Development 2018, 4(3), 401-413. (In Persian).
Roggio, F.; Vitale, E.; Filetti, V.; Rapisarda, V.; Musumeci, G.; Romano, E., Ergonomic evaluation of young agricultural operators using handle equipment through electromyography and vibrations analysis between the fingers. Safety and Health at Work 2022, 13(4), 440-447.
Roman-Liu, D.; Groborz, A.; Tokarski, T., Comparison of risk assessment procedures used in OCRA and ULRA methods. Ergonomics 2013, 56(10), 1584-1598.
Safarzadeh, B.; Nikooy, M.; Tsioras, P. A.; Arman, Z., Ergonomic study of manual loading of log in private poplar plantation in the east of Guilan province. Forest and Wood Products 2022, 75(2), 119-130. (In Persian).
Safarzadeh, B.; Nikooy, M.; Tsioras, P. A.; Arman, Z.; Tavankar, F., Assessing the impact of log manual loading on the physiological load in forest workers. Forest Research and Development 2023, 9(2), 175-187. (In Persian).
Schettino, S.; Minette, L. J.; Lima, R. C. A.; Nascimento, G. S. P.; Caçador, S. S.; Vieira, M. P. L., Forest harvesting in rural properties: Risks and worsening to the worker’s health under the ergonomics approach. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 2021, 82, 103087.
Tsioras, P. A.; Khooshdohbat, M.; Nikooy, M.; Naghdi, R.; Heidari, M., The impact of body posture on heart rate strain during tree felling. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022, 19(18), 11198.
Unver-Okan, S.; Acar, H. H.; Kaya, A., Determination of work postures with different ergonomic risk assessment methods in forest nurseries. Fresenius Environmental Bulletin 2017, 26(12), 7362-7371.
Yaylı, D.; Çalışkan, E., Comparison of Ergonomic Risk Analysis Methods for Working Postures of Forest Nursery Workers. European Journal of Forest Engineering 2019, 5(1), 18-24.
Yovi, E. Y.; Yamada, Y., Strategy to disseminate occupational safety and health information to forestry workers: The felling safety game. Journal of Tropical Forest Science 2015, 213-221.